Patient: Dr. Malpani, my partner, and I are debating between two IVF clinics. One is a large hospital-based clinic, and the other is a smaller standalone clinic. What’s your opinion?
Dr. Malpani: That’s a thoughtful question. First, let’s focus on what matters most—success rates. The clinic you choose should have a proven track record of helping couples like you conceive. However, if both clinics have comparable success rates, other factors like the clinic's setup and approach become crucial.
Patient: We’ve always assumed hospitals are safer because they’re larger and have more resources. Isn’t that better for IVF?
Dr. Malpani: I understand the assumption, but IVF is different from most medical treatments. Infertile couples aren’t sick patients; they just need assistance to conceive. Hospitals are designed to treat illness, not infertility. The complications associated with IVF are extremely rare, especially in good clinics, so the “safety” factor of a hospital is often overstated.
Patient: That’s interesting. I thought hospitals were better equipped for emergencies.
Dr. Malpani: Emergencies in IVF are rare, and standalone clinics are well-equipped to manage them. Hospitals do have resources, but they’re not tailored for infertility care. In fact, hospital bureaucracy—long waiting times, complicated billing processes, and administrative layers—can make the experience frustrating for couples.
Patient: I hadn’t thought about the bureaucracy. What about emotional support?
Dr. Malpani: Emotional support is where standalone clinics truly shine. These clinics focus solely on infertility care. They’re smaller, warmer, and provide a personal touch that hospitals often lack. The staff knows you by name, not just by your file number.
Patient: That does sound more reassuring. But what about the quality of care?
Dr. Malpani: Standalone clinics specialise in IVF, and their systems are designed for it. We don’t just provide treatment—we guide you through every step. Our focus is entirely on helping you conceive, without distractions from other hospital departments.
Patient: Hospitals do seem more profit-driven in some cases. Do you see that happening in IVF care?
Dr. Malpani: Unfortunately, yes. In hospital-based clinics, doctors often have revenue targets and may prioritise meeting those over patient needs. Standalone clinics, on the other hand, depend on their reputation and patient satisfaction to survive. This drives us to provide the best possible care.
Patient: That makes sense. But what if a complication arises?
Dr. Malpani: As I mentioned earlier, the chances of complications in a good IVF clinic are minimal. We’re fully equipped to handle them, and if a rare case requires hospital resources, we have established protocols for quick referrals.
Patient: You’ve given me a lot to think about. Thank you for explaining this so clearly.
Patient: That sounds great. I’ll consider both options. Thanks again!
Subscribe To Our Newsletter
Please subscribe to our newsletter to remain updated about IVF.
